Lecture 4 of 34 · Defending the Undefendable
2. The Pimp
2. The Pimp by Walter Block is a free audio lecture (4:34) at freecapitalists.org, part of the 34-lecture series Defending the Undefendable.
Full text
Transcript
610 words · 3 minutes to read
0:00Chapter 2. The Pimp. From time immemorial, pimps have been treated as parasites who prey on prostitutes. But, in a fair assessment, an examination of the true function of the pimp must be made. An initial point requiring clarification is the claim that pimps use coercion and threats of violence to gather and keep prostitutes on their payrolls. Some pimps do, but does this fact justify condemning the profession itself? Is there any profession that does not have a single practitioner who is not guilty of foul play? There are bricklayers, plumbers, musicians, priests, doctors and lawyers who have violated the rights of their fellow creatures.
0:51But these professions are not qua professions to be condemned in their entirety. And so it should be with the profession of pimping. The actions of any one or even of all pimps together cannot legitimately be used to condemn the profession qua profession, unless the action is a necessary part of the profession. Now the profession of kidnapping small children for ransom is an evil profession, qua profession. Even though some kidnappers may perform good deeds, such as contributing a part of the ransom to charity, or even if all of them do so, the profession does not thereby become less of an abomination, because the action which defines it is evil.
1:42If the action which defines the profession of pimping were evil, then it should be condemned also. In order to evaluate pimping, any extraneous evil acts which may be committed by some pimps must be ignored as having little to do with the profession as such. The function of the pimp qua pimp is that of a broker. In the same way as do brokers of real estate, insurance, stock market shares, investments, commodity futures, etc., the pimp serves the function of bringing together two parties Each party to a transaction at less cost than it would take to bring them together without his good offices. Each party to a transaction served by a broker gains from the brokerage, otherwise they would not patronize him.
2:34And so it is in the case of the pimp. The customer is spared useless or wasteful waiting and searching time. It is easier to phone a pimp for an assignation with a prostitute than to spend time and effort Searching One Out. The customer also has the security of knowing that the prostitute comes recommended. The prostitute benefits too. She gains the time that would otherwise be spent in searching for the customer. She is also protected by the pimp from undesirable customers and from policemen, part of whose profession qua profession is to prevent prostitutes from engaging in voluntary trade with consent. Assignations arranged by the PIMP afford the prostitute additional physical security over street walking or bar hopping.
3:28The prostitute is no more exploited by the PIMP than is the manufacturer exploited by the salesman who drums up business for him, or the actress who pays an agent a percentage of her earnings to find new roles for her. for Her. In these examples, the employer, by means of the employee's services, earns more than the cost of hiring the employee. If this were not so, the employer-employee relationship would not take place. The relationship of the prostitute to the pimp, employer to employee, contains the same mutual advantages. The professional pimp performs the necessary function of brokering. In this performance, he is, if anything, more honorable than many other brokers, such as banking, insurance and the stock market. They rely on restrictive state and federal laws to discourage their competition, whereas the pimp can never use the law to safeguard his position.
Part of a series
Defending the Undefendable
34 lectures, 7.9 hours. See the full series or subscribe by RSS.
Speakers: Friedrich A. Hayek, Murray N. Rothbard, Walter Block.
Questions
About this lecture
- Can I listen to 2. The Pimp free?
- Yes. It plays as audio in the browser on this page, and downloads free with no signup.
- How long is 2. The Pimp?
- The recording runs 4:34.
- Who gave the lecture 2. The Pimp?
- Walter Block delivered it, in the series Defending the Undefendable.
- What series is 2. The Pimp part of?
- It is lecture 4 of 34 in Defending the Undefendable, which is free to stream or download in full.